Benefit Burden – How Rising Health Costs Are Reshaping Madison’s School Budget

EducationMadison

Like with every other preliminary budget in this series, please keep in mind that the numbers Madison starts with here can change between now and when the budget is adopted.

Operating budget moves from ~$55.4M (2024-25 actual) to ~$59.7M (2025-26 revised) to ~$60.0M (2026-27 prelim) representing a ~$350K bump year-over-year into the preliminary, so the big jump comes from the 2024-25 actual to the 2025-26 revised, while growth slows sharply into the 2026-27 prelim.

Madison Operating Budget

2024-25 actual to 2026-27 preliminary

2024-25 Actual
$55.4M
2025-26 Revised
$59.7M
2026-27 Prelim
$60.0M

The big jump comes from the 2024-25 actual to the 2025-26 revised budget, while growth slows sharply into the 2026-27 preliminary.

The tax levy tells a different story- that rises from ~$48.6M (2025-26 revised) to ~$52.0M (2026-27 prelim), a ~$3.4M increase (+ 7%). This while state aid falls from ~$4.75M (2025-26 revised) to ~$4.40M (2026-27 prelim.) due to a big drop in Extraordinary Aid (according to the notes).

Fund balance use drops significantly as well from ~$2.56M (2025-26 revised) to ~$1.24M (2026-27 prelim.) with both maintenance reserve and capital reserve withdrawals going to zero.

So the Districts is pulling more and more from the tax levy and holding off on touching reserves as the state give shrinks.

Tax Levy Rises as State Aid Falls

2025-26 revised to 2026-27 preliminary

Tax Levy: 2025-26 Revised
$48.6M
Tax Levy: 2026-27 Prelim
$52.0M
State Aid: 2025-26 Revised
$4.75M
State Aid: 2026-27 Prelim
$4.40M

The local tax levy increases by about $3.4M while state aid declines, largely due to a reduced Extraordinary Aid projection.

On thing is clear in looking at Madison’s Budget – Regular Instruction is not in the driver’s seat as it moves from ~$16.23M (2024-25 actual) to ~$16.66M (2025-26 revised) and then down to ~$16.16M (2026-27 prelim.). While it is relatively flat over the full period, it rises into the 2025-26 revised budget before declining in the 2026-27 prelim.

Special education instruction tracks similar from ~$5.24M (2024-25 actual) to ~$5.68M (2025-26 revised) to ~$5.49M (2026-27 prelim.).

When you look at the internals it gets interesting.

Emotional Regulation Impairment increases significantly, while Resource Room declines as a result of teachers moving from Resource Room to ERI along with a reduction of staff in Resource Room by two FTEs.

Preschool disabilities also declines, with notes pointing to a one FTE reduction.

Instruction Is Not Driving the Increase

Regular instruction and special education instruction both decline from revised to preliminary

Regular Instruction
2024-25 Actual
$16.23M
2025-26 Revised
$16.66M
2026-27 Prelim
$16.16M
Special Education Instruction
2024-25 Actual
$5.24M
2025-26 Revised
$5.68M
2026-27 Prelim
$5.49M

Out-of-district and placement costs continue to rise unlike some other District’s we’ve looked at.

Total tuition-related spending moves from ~$2.68M (2024-25 actual) to ~$2.82M (2025-26 revised) to ~$2.89M (2026-27 prelim.).

Tuition and Placement Costs Keep Rising

Unlike some districts, Madison’s placement-related tuition costs continue upward

2024-25 Actual
$2.68M
2025-26 Revised
$2.82M
2026-27 Prelim
$2.89M

Total tuition-related spending continues to rise across the three-year comparison.

Student support services is mixed.

Health services bumps up from ~$528K (2024-25 actual) to ~$533K (2025-26 revised) to ~$584K (2026-27 prelim.) – AEDs, EpiPens, and substitute nurse coverage per notes.

Extraordinary or other support services rises into the revised budget and then drops slightly in the preliminary, from ~$2.39M to ~$2.27M.

But the notes indicate staffing changes, including paraprofessionals being replaced with contracted services, which complicates how that line should be interpreted.

Child Study Teams drops from ~$1.87M (2024-25 actual) to ~$1.77M (2025-26 revised) to ~$1.70M (2026-27 prelim) with notes pointing to reduced supplies and services.

Reductions show up clearly in support and admin areas.

Improvement of instruction drops sharply from ~$1.36M (2024-25 actual) to ~$1.28M (2025-26 revised) to ~$890K (2026-27 prelim) – instructional supplies were moved out of that line and a secretary position was reduced according to the notes.

General administration drops from ~$1.17M (2025-26 revised) to ~$1.02M (2026-27 prelim), with notes referencing a separation agreement last year.

School administration also declines from ~$2.37M to ~$2.18M.

While these are meaningful reductions on paper, some appear tied to one-time items or reclassification v. foundational changes.

Athletics is going north, increasing from ~$913K (2024-25 actual) to ~$939K (2025-26 revised) to ~$1.04M (2026-27 prelim), with notes pointing to stipend increases under negotiation.

Security is worth noting because it dips in the revised budget and then rebounds above the prior actual, moving from ~$164K (2024-25 actual) to ~$131K (2025-26 revised) to ~$183K (2026-27 prelim). Residents may want to ask some hard questions here – a pretty penny for someone to monitor a door.

Security Dips, Then Rebounds

Security spending rises above the 2024-25 actual in the preliminary budget

2024-25 Actual
$164K
2025-26 Revised
$131K
2026-27 Prelim
$183K

The line dips in the revised budget, then rebounds above the prior actual in the 2026-27 preliminary.

Transportation on a steady ascend – ~$2.54M (2024-25 actual) to ~$2.67M (2025-26 revised) to ~$2.77M (2026-27 prelim) with special education transportation a primary factor.

Transportation Keeps Climbing

Special education transportation remains a primary factor

2024-25 Actual
$2.54M
2025-26 Revised
$2.67M
2026-27 Prelim
$2.77M

Transportation continues its steady upward movement across the full comparison period.

The biggest pressure point in the entire budget is….you guessed it… employee benefits (I should just copy and paste this line for every budget). The line moves from ~$8.16M (2024-25 actual) to ~$10.06M (2025-26 revised) to ~$12.31M (2026-27 prelim).

Employee Benefits Keep Climbing

The biggest pressure point in the Madison budget

2024-25 Actual
$8.16M
2025-26 Revised
$10.06M
2026-27 Prelim
$12.31M

Employee benefits increase by more than $4M over the three-year comparison period.

Health benefits alone jumps from ~$6.53M to ~$8.30M to ~$10.90M.

Health Benefits Alone Explain Much of the Pressure

Health benefits inside employee benefits

2024-25 Actual
$6.53M
2025-26 Revised
$8.30M
2026-27 Prelim
$10.90M

Health benefits rise by roughly $4.4M from the 2024-25 actual to the 2026-27 preliminary budget.

That increase by itself pretty much explains the rising tax levy despite multiple areas going down or staying flat.

Capital spending drops off significantly from ~$694K (2025-26 revised) to just ~$6.6K (2026-27 preliminary).

Capital Spending Drops Off

Capital outlay nearly disappears in the 2026-27 preliminary budget

2024-25 Actual
$414K
2025-26 Revised
$695K
2026-27 Prelim
$6.6K

The budget notes indicate no current plans to draw from capital reserve, and prior transfers into capital projects are removed.

The budget notes indicate no current plans to draw from capital reserve, and prior transfers into capital projects are removed.

Debt service, however, continues to rise, with the district noting that the first principal payment on new debt begins in 2026.

Source Materials

Support NJ21st and Stay Involved

Your support helps keep local and state government transparent and accountable.


💡

Make a Financial Contribution

Your contribution fuels our reporting, public records work and statewide transparency projects.

Support NJ21st
✍️

Contribute Your Writing and Get Involved

Have insights or documents about local or statewide issues? Become a community contributor and help strengthen public understanding.

Get Involved
📬

Subscribe for Daily Updates

Get daily updates on local and state government decisions, documents, hearings and accountability work delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe on Substack
f Follow us on Facebook
X Follow us on X

NJ21st is an independent nonprofit civic journalism project focused on transparency, public records and accountability in both local and state government.

Leave a Reply